Plants DO talk !
March 16, 2005 at 11:30 am #5332810712Participant
Ya, they do [?]talk but electrically,
Many days before I saw on TV that there is a circuit in plant body i.e. whole body is a closed circuit. And if we cut one plant of say a species A , then some electrical changes occur in that plant, also some electrical changes ocur in other plants in that area, this area is much big.
so do plants really communicate , or these chnges are merely side effects of some other thing. I mean do they convey message or this is just what happens???
Also, why is there an electrical circuit in the plant body, does it play any IMP role in explaining HOH and mineral transport in tall plants ? ? ? Why is it created [ where is the cell ] ?
-ve / +ve terminal ? ? ? Ohhh. soooomaaany qs. very less time, hummm
sorry for bad English,
March 16, 2005 at 4:17 pm #20538Chris4Participant
What are these electrical circuits?
If you pull a plant out of the ground then of course there will be changes in the surrounding plants because you have caused a change in the soil and environment etc. Same with if you cut a part of the plant off. There will be a change in the air or environment and this will affect the surrounding plants. For a very brief period.
I cant explain it very much, but its just an idea.
I’ve been thinking recently. In todays scientific society if you want to be known by other scientists/media (or get on TV) then you have to either discover something amazing or say/research something strange/controversial. Researching something strange gets you on TV. For example – There are loads of strange stories now adays about mathematicians who have come up with a formula for whether a marriage will last etc (A formula for a good marriage, just one of the ones i remember). Crazy, but people waste time and money researching absolute rubbish.
Say your a plant scientist. Your not likely to make the news headlines are you? Unless you do some sketchy research and tell everyone that you have evidence that plants talk. What does everyone else think? Surely you can see what im trying to say?
March 16, 2005 at 5:01 pm #20541protozoanParticipant
Yes plants can comunnicate. In the forest when some danger occur to some plant, this plant can release a chemical substance which spread through air and other plants can catch it and be prepared for danger. This is all what i know about plant comunication.
March 16, 2005 at 5:33 pm #20544Chris4Participantquote protozoan:
Yes plants can comunnicate. In the forest when some danger occur to some plant, this plant can release a chemical substance which spread through air and other plants can catch it and be prepared for danger. This is all what i know about plant comunication.[/quote]
How do plants prepare for danger? 😕
March 16, 2005 at 6:10 pm #20547protozoanParticipant
They can start to produce defence substances against parasites or make stronger their protection by increasing of the production of these substances. I saw it on TV but i forgot about what exactly it was. But comunication of this kind surely exists.
March 17, 2005 at 6:38 am #205832810712Participant
I saw that plant communication on discovery or natgeo, I don’t exactly remember .
What the changes in air and soil be, they are limited for smaller area , but that scientist found electrical changes[ voltage variation , as per I remember] in plants at a considerable distance.I think, if his discovery is irrespective of direction of air currents then it is true,
But, how is the circuit formed? ? ?
Is it due to mineral ions or whattype electron flow or ion flow circuit it is? ? ?
electron flow circuit is less likely to be there, I think.
Also, protozoan, what U told was an intraspecefic way. this is intra and inter both!!!
May 18, 2005 at 10:30 pm #22718darehshouriParticipantquote Chris4:
How do plants prepare for danger? :?[/quote]
Plants can prepare for danger. But, I think release of chemical substances through air is not realistic!
May 19, 2005 at 2:20 am #22723
May 19, 2005 at 7:31 pm #22765MrMisteryParticipant
Actually it is true. I have also heard of this
May 19, 2005 at 8:16 pm #22771
I heard tobacco plants can do this
May 19, 2005 at 10:20 pm #22779MicrasteriasParticipantquote mithrilhack:
Do you know what they as chemical substances are?
May 20, 2005 at 3:14 am #22792
This kind of communication is probably not unique to sagebrush and wild tobacco, but Karban says they do seem to be an especially well-matched pair. Sagebrush produces huge amounts of methyl jasmonate, the chemical that appears to trigger the defenses of many plants, including wild tobacco. When you cut a sagebrush plant, all that methyl jasmonate gets released into the air. In contrast, wild tobacco plants don’t seem to react when other wild tobacco plants get chomped on, which makes sense when you consider that wild tobacco produces methyl jasmonate in relatively small quantities.
http://www.ontariosciencecentre.ca/sciz … obacco.asp
July 21, 2012 at 5:13 pm #111892suzidoc8Participant
i would just say that they communicate as they have to work out together so they need to be in contact with each other!
August 2, 2012 at 10:14 am #111999greatmona1Participant
Hi ,2810712 you have posted an impotent natural tips . I mean you have enough knowledge about nature.Your all idea are correct but I have no enough knowledge about talk of plants ,I only know that they must have a fillings .Thank you.
August 4, 2012 at 4:32 pm #112028GastonParticipant
I have gone thru the comments given by others and most of the commenters agree that plants do communicate (talk). However no one proved scientifically how these plants talk! For that reason and to the extend I know plants, I comment that plants they do not talk.
August 8, 2012 at 12:09 pm #112049JackBeanParticipant
there’s difference between commucation and talking 🙄 of course plants do not talk, but they do communicate (e.g. by ethylene, but there are other ways, for example the roots in soil)
September 19, 2012 at 12:30 pm #112400vazqueParticipant
Plants cannot talk to each other. But, they have sense, they can feel, they can make sounds, Plants sense light and sense gravity and have specific responses.
September 21, 2012 at 2:36 am #112427CatParticipant
They are called semiochemicals, pheromones, etc.
http://www.linv.org/images/about_pdf/Co … 202008.pdf
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.