Biology Forum Human Biology GOT A QUESTION

2 voices
2 replies
  • Author
    Posts
    • #7102
      biotchr
      Participant

      O.K. A student asked me a question the other day that stumped me and I bet there is a really simple answer.

      We are talking about alternative inheritance patterns in humans, specifically sex-linked traits. I showed my class a karyotype in continuing to reinforce what chromosomes are and do. The karyotype was taken from a man that had XYY disorder.

      The question was how does one go about inheriting the XYY disorder. I explained about nondisjunction during meiosis and subsequent formation of gametes. And also, I think the XYY disorder is actually not necessarily inherited genetically, it is just a mistake in meiosis. I believe that is true and the fact that XYY is supposedly inherited like some other human trait is a misconception. Then again, it is "inherited" to a certain degree in that it was due to a condition in the parent, of course by that logic so would FAS (Fetal Alcohol Syndrome.

      SOMEONE PLEASE CORRECT ME HERE IF I AM WRONG.

      Now for the real meat! How could a sperm be YY so as to fertilze an egg, resulting in XYY? The only result of a possible nondisjuction event in a male should be XY, right? In that case, XXY is an easy phenomenon to explain. But XYY cant really be explained, can it??????

      I NEED SOMEONE TO HELP ME EXPLAIN HOW A "NONDISJUNCT" SPERM CELL COULD HOUSE A YY COMBINATION IN ORDER TO RESULT IN AN XYY PRODUCT.

      Any help would be greatly appreciated. Thank you.

    • #69708
      Dr.Stein
      Participant

      Here is for you. Sorry for the bad quality, I just scanned it from my book 🙂


      Attachments:

    • #69733
      biotchr
      Participant
      quote Dr.Stein:

      Here is for you. Sorry for the bad quality, I just scanned it from my book 🙂

      Ah hah. Got it. I was only considering the reduction of Meosis I and forgetting about mitotic events in Meosis II.

      Whoops! Thank you, and my students thank you.

You must be logged in to reply to this topic.

Members