Biology Forum Community General Discussion Jellyfish: Plant or animal?

18 voices
23 replies
  • Author
    Posts
    • #4645
      autumn
      Participant

      I’m kind of confused with this question:

      When a jellyfish is removed from its saltwater environment and put into fresh water it swells and bursts. Do you think a jellyfish is a plant or an animal? Why? [Hint: think about how plant cells and animal cells react when placed in a solution.]

      Help?

    • #47657
      alextemplet
      Participant

      It’s an animal, part of the phylum cnideria.

    • #47677
      Khaiy
      Participant

      The hint talks about cells being hypertonic or hypotonic to their solutions. But think about this: Animal cells have cell membranes, plant cells have cell walls… what do you know about those?

    • #47682
      kabuto
      Participant
      quote :

      When a jellyfish is removed from its saltwater environment and put into fresh water it swells and bursts

      i hv a question.
      would the entire jellyfish burst or just the cells in it?
      will the same thing happen to human if we were put in a solution hypotonic enough since we also have no cell wall?

    • #47710
      Poison
      Participant

      Your cells can burst if they are put in hypotonic solution.
      You do not burst but you gain water in fresh water. Think about people killed and thrown in rivers. They get lots of water and become very heavy.

      PS: No need to "think" about jellyfish, it is an animal. 🙂

    • #47735
      AstusAleator
      Participant

      Your epidermis is pretty tough, and resistant to hyper-osmosis. However, if one was to inject pure H20 into your bloodstream, it would cause your erythrocytes to burst. Furthermore (I think this has been discussed on this forum) if you were to drink an ungodly amount of water, it could do damage to your internal orgrans (though epithelial tissue is resistant to that in general)

    • #47737
      kabuto
      Participant

      how about the jellyfish? 🙄

    • #47775
      MrMistery
      Participant

      the cells of the jellyfish would burst..

    • #47804
      kabuto
      Participant
      quote MrMistery:

      the cells of the jellyfish would burst..

      thank you for clarifying..
      so, there wont be any dramatic scene here

    • #47811
      MrMistery
      Participant

      only the death of the animal 😀

    • #48067

      some of our cells do burst if the water potential is strange in the blood, for instance if the plasma has a pO2 of -20 and a red blood cell has -10 then the water will leave the cell and it will shrivel as it travels along the concentration gradient
      also if the pO2 was reversed i.e. cell -20 and plasma -10 then water will be taken up by the cell and it would burst

      although generally the the blood is about the same water potential inside and outside of the cells to prevent such things from happening, so make sure no one puts H2o in ur blood and u’ll pretty much be fine

      as for the jellyfish no thought is needed as its definately a animal, it does everything an animal does, most of all it moves and hve u ever seen a plant move? other than from wind and fungus flytraps no

      sry if i blabbered on abit lol

    • #48072
      D
      Participant

      i think jellyfish are gay

    • #48076
      Poison
      Participant

      Gay? Why did you say that? And what’s the relation between your post and the subject?

    • #48260
      red_rose
      Participant

      of course jelly fish are animals. do you really think that scientists have gotten that wrong all this time and that they really are plants. i doubt really doubt that

    • #48273
      rach
      Participant

      i agree. support the gay jellyfish association!

    • #48305
      beluga fiction
      Participant

      Jellyfishes are animals, but they can have a simbiotic relationship with different kinds of algaes.

    • #48389
      zalaskit
      Participant

      now what PossiblE use could that reply have had.

      p.s. maybe the jellyfish think that YOU are

    • #60510
      maofmany2001
      Participant

      Could you please tell me exactly WHY the jellyfish burst?

    • #60577
      Dr.Stein
      Participant

      The answer is already on the first page 8)

    • #74858
      kashi1134
      Participant

      This made me giggle a little bit.. I just finished a exam with the question of whether a jellyfish is a plant or animal, and why it would burst in fresh water…
      And yes, jellyfish are homosexual beasts.

    • #74859
      kashi1134
      Participant

      But -WHY- are jellyfish an animal?
      And why do they burst in fresh water?

    • #74868
      Darby
      Participant

      How much do you understand about osmosis? That will lead to the second answer.

      Jellyfish don’t photosynthesize, don’t have cell walls, and digest food internally – that’s enough to differentiate them from the other multicellular groups, the plants and the fungi.

    • #74889
      orbit
      Participant
      quote D:

      i think jellyfish are gay

      That’s great, well done! Big clap for you! 😐

      Maybe a biology forum isn’t the best place for you. Just a thought.

    • #74890
      orbit
      Participant
      quote rach:

      i agree. support the gay jellyfish association!

      And maybe you should find another forum too.

You must be logged in to reply to this topic.

Members